Engaging with the Expressivist Objection
نویسنده
چکیده
منابع مشابه
Disability, identity and the "expressivist objection".
The practice of prenatal screening for disability is sometimes objected to because of the hurt and offence such practices may cause to people currently living with disabilities. This objection is commonly termed "the expressivist objection". In response to the objection it is standardly claimed that disabilities are analogous to illnesses. And just as it would be implausible to suppose reductio...
متن کاملThe expressivist objection to prenatal testing: the experiences of families living with genetic disease.
The expressivist objection to prenatal testing is acknowledged as a significant critique of prenatal testing practices most commonly advanced by disability rights supporters. Such writers argue that prenatal testing and selective termination practices are objectionable as they express disvalue not only of the foetus being tested, but also of disabled people as a whole, by focusing exclusively o...
متن کاملThe expressivist objection to prenatal diagnosis: can it be laid to rest?
Received 24 May 2007 Accepted 24 May 2007 Tom Shakespeare’s book Disability rights and wrongs is very rich and interesting and ought to be compulsory reading for anyone interested in the relation between disability and medical ethics. In my short contribution to this symposium on the book, I will focus on a particular aspect of his discussion of prenatal diagnosis and termination of pregnancy. ...
متن کاملPrenatal Bioethics, Advocacy, and the Requirement of a Third Moral Space
This paper addresses the question of how, in a futures context derived from perspectives surrounding clinical genetics, prenatal diagnosis and disability advocacy, there is a requirement for a third moral space. Just what this requirement is, and some of the reasons for it, shall be discussed here. In order to ground the paper in the current situation, attention is drawn, firstly to a chapter i...
متن کاملErrors upon Errors: A Reply to Joyce
In his response to my paper „The Error in the Error Theory‟ criticizing his and J. L. Mackie‟s moral error theory, Richard Joyce finds my treatment of his position inaccurate and my interpretation of morality implausible. In this reply I clarify my objection, showing that it retains its force against their error theory, and I clarify my interpretation of morality, showing that Joyce‟s objection...
متن کامل